Skip to content

New York Style Pizza

By Patrick Hogan
Pin Recipe

A 65% hydration New York-style pizza dough mixed cold, fermented for 2-3 days, and baked hot with tomato sauce, Trader Joe's low moisture whole milk mozzarella, pecorino romano, and oregano. The applied formula is 65% hydration and makes 3 dough balls.

New York Style Pizza hero image
Prep Time
3 days 4 hr 30 min
Cook Time
6 min
Total Time
3 days 4 hr 36 min
Yield
3 16-inch pizzas
Your recipe
3 balls × 480g · 16-inch pizzas · Outdoor Oven · 65% hydration

Ingredients

Dough

  • 861g Kirkland Organic All-Purpose Flour
  • 560g water
  • 2.15g SAF gold instant yeast
  • 17.2g fine sea salt

Pizza Sauce

  • 1 can Bianco di Napoli whole peeled tomatoes

Pizza toppings (per pizza; 3 total)

Instructions

Dough

  1. Fill a pitcher with water and ice and let it chill down. Weigh out the water only — keep the ice out of the mixer bowl.
  2. Add the water, flour, fine sea salt, and SAF gold instant yeast to the spiral mixer all at once.
  3. Mix at 40% speed until the dough reads 72°F on your IR thermometer. Scrape the bowl and hook down with your bench scraper if dough climbs.
  4. Transfer the dough to your bench. Knead shortly, guide dough with bench scraper into the form of a ball, place in a bowl, cover with saran wrap, and allow it to rest at room temperature for 1.5h.
  5. Divide and shape dough into 3 balls, shooting for 480g each (1440g total dough). Pull four times in gentle circles on your unfloured bench until smooth on the top. Pinch any bottom seam that remains. Circular dough balls make circular pizzas 🙂 (video).
  6. Grease your proofing container with canola oil. Transfer the dough to the container with your bench scraper. After placing in a proofing container, lightly oil your hands and gently rub the top of the dough to make it less sticky and retain moisture. Cover and place in the refrigerator for 2-3 days.

Pre-Assembly

  1. Pizza sauce: Drain off ¼ cup of water from the can, then hand crush or mill the tomatoes to a smooth, easy-to-spread consistency. Place sauce in a small bowl and cover with saran wrap. It's ok to freeze / refrigerate for a bit, but always bring to room temperature immediately before use to avoid gummy pizza.
  2. Cheese: Grate the mozzarella and finely grate the romano.
  3. Bench flour: Mix 50/50 semolina + all purpose flour in a small bowl and set aside.

Pizza Assembly

  1. The day you plan to bake, remove dough from the refrigerator and allow the dough to rest for 2 hours.
  2. Preheat your oven on low for 30 minutes with rotation activated, then begin prepping the pizza.
  3. Lightly dust your wooden peel with bench flour.
  4. Remove dough with your bench scraper and cover liberally with bench flour.
  5. Stretch dough to 16 inches (video).
  6. Place the dough on the peel with the rough bottom side facing up.
  7. Apply sauce to the pizza in a circular motion with a large spoon all the way to the raised portion that will become your crust.
  8. Pinch dried oregano in your fingers to oxidize and spread over the top of the sauce.
  9. Spread Romano cheese evenly over the entire pizza, covering as much of the sauce as possible.
  10. Scatter the shredded mozzarella evenly over the top.

Launch / Bake

  1. Once the pizza is built, turn the oven off. Wait until the center of the stone reads 630°F on your IR thermometer.
  2. Turn the oven back on to medium with rotation off and launch the pizza in the center of the stone. Turn rotation back off.
  3. Bake for 5-6 minutes, rotating frequently. If the bottom is running ahead of the top, slide the pizza onto a screen just before the bottom reaches the doneness you want and finish the bake on the screen.
  4. Remove the pizza from the oven with your large metal peel and place on a wire rack.
  5. Transfer the pizza to a cutting board, slice, and return to the wire rack to keep crispy.
  6. Serve hot.

Equipment

Notes

  • This dough is 65% hydration and makes 3 × 480g balls (1440g total).
  • Trader Joe's whole milk low moisture mozzarella is a particularly good choice for this pizza. If the shredded cheese clumps or is difficult to distribute, freeze it briefly after shredding; this can help the strands separate.
  • Olive oil and sugar have been withheld from this recipe due to high temperatures of the pizza oven to prevent burning. These are often employed in lower temperature ovens to improve browning.
  • Great article with a lot info.
  • Good video with more info, not always reliable but pretty informative.
  • Lots of info in r/Pizza from the community.
  • I recommend making a couple more balls than you plan to eat to start. It will take 5 bakes to settle in and making more each time will shorten the learning curve.
  • If launching is tricky, build the pizza on parchment on your peel. Launch with the parchment, then slide it out after 1 minute.